By Michael A. Fletcher
September 12, 2005
Washington Post
Hurricane Katrina has thrust the twin issues of race and poverty at President
Bush, who faces steep challenges in dealing with both because of a domestic
agenda that envisions deep cuts in long-standing anti-poverty programs and
relationships with many black leaders frayed by years of mutual suspicion.
In the storm's aftermath, the White House has been scrambling to quell
perceptions that race was a factor in the slow federal response to Katrina and
that its policies have contributed to the festering poverty propelled into
public view by the disaster.
Last week, Bush summoned faith-based relief organizations and religious leaders
-- many of them African American -- to a White House meeting to discuss his
vision for providing long-term help for impoverished people displaced by the
storm.
He dispatched Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice to her home state of Alabama.
He also has had his political surrogates reach out to civil rights groups that
previously felt ignored by the White House.
"Katrina has been an attention-getting experience for this administration,"
said Bruce S. Gordon, president and chief executive officer of the NAACP. "It's
clear that the administration has not had [black and poor people] as high on
their priority list as they should have."
Angry about how an affiliate of the NAACP portrayed him in a 2000 political ad,
Bush has rejected invitations to speak at the organization's past five
conventions, making him the first sitting president in more than 80 years not to
address the group. NAACP Chairman Julian Bond has excoriated Bush as a
reactionary conservative. In the past week, however, Gordon has had multiple
conversations with top administration officials and fielded calls from aides to
White House Deputy Chief of Staff Karl Rove.
"They wanted to be sure they knew what we were thinking," Gordon said.
Bush also has resolved to tackle the poverty that ensnared 28 percent of New
Orleans residents and many others on the Gulf Coast. Many of those poor people
were unable to heed warnings to evacuate as the storm approached, compounding
the disaster as tens of thousands of mostly black residents overwhelmed sparse
government provisions when they sought shelter at the Superdome and convention
center in New Orleans.
"Sometimes it takes a natural disaster to reveal a social disaster," said Jim
Wallis, editor of Sojourner's, a liberal evangelical journal.
During Tuesday's White House meeting with 20 religious leaders and
representatives from relief groups, Bush vowed to provide job programs, health
care, life-skills training and housing aid to those displaced by the storm.
Echoing a position taken by some civil rights leaders, he asserted that it was
insensitive to refer to the poor people fleeing New Orleans as "refugees," a
term that for some evokes people fleeing their native country.
When some people at the meeting said that New Orleans residents and local
businesses should reap much of the economic benefit from the huge investment
that will be required to rebuild the city, Bush readily agreed, according to one
participant.
"He didn't receive many of these concerns as some kind of 'race' issue," said
C. Jay Matthews, a Cleveland minister who attended the meeting. "There was a
feeling that maybe what we have been doing up to now to fight poverty maybe
hasn't been effective and we need to move toward long-term solutions."
But some skeptics fear these reassuring words are a disguise for pursuing
long-held conservative goals that are viewed with hostility by many black
leaders. Congressional Republicans, for example, have voiced opposition to
federal programs that set aside government contracts for minorities. And Bush
has already moved to suspend the law requiring federal contractors to pay
workers the average wage in the region, holding down salaries for many minority
laborers.
In the place of traditional poverty programs, Bush has touted faith-based
social service programs, calling them more efficient and effective than those
run by the government. Many programs of an earlier generation, he says, have
served only to perpetuate the plight of the poor.
Overcoming mistrust of blacks compounded by Katrina is an important hurdle in
one of Bush's political goals -- making the GOP more competitive with
traditionally Democratic African Americans.
"What we've been trying to do is what we believe will help us close the gap we
see in America in terms of education, health care, home ownership and wealth,"
said Ken Mehlman, chairman of the Republican National Committee. "We have
policies that will actually achieve those goals."
To underscore his outreach efforts, when the president toured a hurricane
evacuee shelter near Baton Rouge last week, he was accompanied by the Rev. T.D.
Jakes, a prominent black evangelist who has known Bush for years. He also went
to New Orleans yesterday. Those trips came after Bush was criticized for having
little contract with poor, black victims during an earlier visit.
"I mean, it's puzzling, given his immediate response during 9/11, that he did
not feel a greater sense of empathy towards the folks that were experiencing
this enormous disaster," Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill.) said yesterday on ABC's
"This Week."
Whatever approach the administration takes as it moves forward, any
Katrina-inspired increase in federal outlays to alleviate poverty would
represent a sharp turn for an administration that has moved to reshape
government by reducing outlays for social programs by encouraging individual
ownership of -- and responsibility for -- everything from housing to health care
and retirement accounts. Meanwhile, White House budget makers have projected
deep cuts in traditional poverty programs, including food stamps and public
housing.
But the calamity spawned by New Orleans has placed Bush under new pressure. A
poll last week by the Pew Research Center for the People and the Press found
that two-thirds of African Americans believe the government's response to the
storm would have been faster if most of the victims had been white. Also, 71
percent of blacks agree that the disaster revealed that racial inequality
remains a major problem in the country -- a sentiment shared by 32 percent of
whites.
A prominent Louisiana politician called this perception unfair. "The two
parishes south of New Orleans, St. Bernard and Plaquemines, are mostly white.
They are devastated and they arguably got a lot less attention than New
Orleans," said former Louisiana senator John Breaux (D), who has worked closely
with Bush. "A lot of people didn't get out because they didn't have a car. This
is more a problem of poverty, rather than race."
Rep. Barbara T. Lee (D-Calif.), however, accused Bush of being indifferent to
the poor. "If anyone ever doubted that there are two Americas, this disaster and
our government's shameful response to it have made the division clear for all to
see."
Addressing a meeting of black Baptists in Miami last Wednesday, Democratic
National Committee Chairman Howard Dean said the government's slow response
revealed "the ugly truth that skin color, age and economics played a significant
role in who survived and who did not."
Michael L. Williams, the only black member of the elected Railroad Commission
of Texas and a longtime Bush friend, said the racial and class divisions pushed
into the national debate by Katrina present a formidable test for Bush. The
answers, he said, will come with how Bush addresses the underlying issues.
"It isn't surprising that African Americans across the country feel pain for
the victims of this disaster," Williams said. "When people feel pain, they want
to find someone to blame. There is no doubt that it adds to the challenge facing
us. But the real story is going to be what it always is: What is really being
done about education? About jobs? About housing?"
|